+ASSESS OR DIAGNOSE?

++++++++++++++++++++

Why do the ‘experts’ diagnose an individual while they ‘assess’ a family?  Is the distinguishing factor a cultural assumption-belief that a family is made up of autonomous individuals?  Wrong.  Everyone one of us is formed from our start within an environment that influenced our development, and in severely infant-child abusing families it is obvious to me that the abusing parent is ‘spilling over’ into their child’s ‘personal space’ as the autonomy of the child is left out of the developmental story.  If all children were treated like autonomous people all their universal rights would be respected and met, which is obviously so NOT the case when infant-child abuse happens.

I do not believe healthy autonomy exists within unsafe, insecurely attached abusive human relationships and environments that condone abuse.  If abuse is allowed to happen at all, as far as I am concerned it is being condoned:  Allowed = condone.

I do not believe that when considering and/or dealing with MOST so-called ‘mental illnesses’ that we can have it both ways.  We cannot ‘diagnose’ individuals without ‘diagnosing’ the family that formed that individual.  If we are not willing to accept THIS as reality, then we better ‘assess’ individuals while we ‘assess’ the family that formed them.

In my view, assessment is the direction that offers the most factual and realistic opportunity to affect true HEALING.  All other approaches to most ‘mental illness’ problems — which includes abuse because I believe abuse only happens as an expression of ‘mental illness’  — address ‘symptoms’ without assessing or addressing actual cause.

We can continue to believe the old myth and fallacy that ‘mental illness’ is genetic.  Genes manifest themselves through epigenetic processes that happen when our genetic-expression ‘machinery’ detects a need for a body to adapt to a particular kind of environment.  Our genetic well-being (and therefore our overall well-being) is thus directly tied to the conditions of ill-being or well-being of the environment that forms us – during every instant of our lifetime.

++++++++++++++++++++++++

If we were to listen to the best orchestra in the world play the most complex and beautiful song we can imagine (assuming the piece appeals to our cultural tastes), what we would be listening to in any ongoing instant of time is simply a reflection of what has ‘happened in the past’ as it transfers into ‘what is happening in the present’.  Because we would have no reason to be listening along as a part of this musical experience while at the same time anticipating any abrupt STOP in the music in the middle of the song doesn’t mean that all possibilities for what COULD or MIGHT happen in the future don’t exist.

If we included in our symphony experience a conscious awareness of the nearly unbelievable history that has led up to this moment in time, we would be overwhelmed.  All of the billions of decisions that led to our specific birth as listeners, the decisions that were made back in time that led to the existence of every musician, of everyone who made every instrument we are listening to, who wrote the songs, how this ‘event’ was able to exist because ‘it got put together’ is not something we often include in our conscious awareness.  Our excluding of these thoughts and the information they might relate to does not mean that ALL that information is not a part of what we experience.

If we are going to simply say that so-called ‘mental illness’ is a result of ‘bad genes’ we are excluding vast amounts of information related to what we think we are talking about in a very similar way.

If we think about information in a familiar framework today, we can think about binary code.  Because life as we know it, including our own, actually happens on an atomic and molecular basis where information is transmitted through electrical signals and pulses of information, all we come down to is the equivalent of binary code.

If we think about our entire history as a species, our entire specie’s story of our life here on earth as being contained within our DNA, we only have one part of the story.  Somehow this story is continuing on and we each have our part in it.

While DNA contains the story of our past, it is the DNA’s ‘middle people’ that transform the story of the past into the story of the present.  I don’t know exactly HOW this happens, of course.  In fact, there are probably only a very few researchers alive today who are beginning to detect the truth about how our epigenetic processes work.

Right now it is assumed that epigenetic mechanisms are able to detect conditions within the environment so that these mechanisms can tell our DNA genetic codes how to combine with one another, how to operate, and how to express the DNA information.

Right now it is assumed that even though the epigenetic changes that happen in one generation can be passed down through successive generations (and often are), it is believed that these changes are NOT changing our DNA – or our human story.

BUT it is also becoming known that it is probably true that if the conditions that created patterns of change in DNA expression — as contained in the epigentic changes of DNA communication about the environment and hence in our DNA’s expression — remain in existence long enough, our DNA might very well EVENTUALLY change in adaptation.

++++++++++++++++

This means to me that unlike my symphony image, being human means that the ongoing song-story that we are a part of CAN and DOES change as it goes along, and these changes can be passed down the generations through epigenetic processes that very well MIGHT and CAN change the very essence of our specie’s story within our DNA.

I am coming to understand that this ENTIRE PROCESS is about attachment.  In a great, safe and secure world full of plenty and without toxicity, our epigenetic ‘middle people’ do not have to instruct our DNA to make extreme changes to adapt to trauma.  This version of the picture happens when attachment can happen within a benevolent world.

On the other hand, when attachment is unsafe and insecure within a malevolent environment, our epigentic ‘middle people’ have a much bigger job to do.  They have to tell our DNA about these hostile and malevolent conditions in our environment so our DNA can change its expression to best ensure ongoing life IN SPITE of the traumas and difficulties present.

Playing in an orchestra with well constructed instruments that do not break to pieces in the middle of a song is one thing.  But if, all of a sudden, every instrument develops some kind of critical ailment, the song is going to CHANGE drastically as a result.

If all the instruments remain intact and fine, but suddenly some mysterious sneezing gas is released into the musical arena, the song that was playing is going to change itself, also.

We cannot afford to pretend that the exact conditions of our earliest developmental environment does not profoundly influence the way our DNA manifests itself.  Just because the potential exists of a beautiful song does not mean that within conditions of some environments that beautiful song will NOT be played.

Serious attachment difficulties in early human relationships are obviously far worse than sneezing gas sneezes.  But we have to realize that the nature and quality of our earliest attachment experiences directly communicate to the growing and developing human body-brain what the condition of the world ACTUALLY is – and what it is going to be like in the future.

Our entire physiological systems are designed to tell us – just as clearly as if they were receiving instructions in binary code – what is to be approached and included as life-sustaining in our lifetime along with what is to be avoided and excluded because it is NOT life-sustaining in our lifetime.

This is ATTACHMENT information:  Attach to the good and healthy, do not attach to the bad and unhealthy.

This all begins to be orchestrated (actually from before our conception) through our earliest HUMAN attachment interactions.  In environments of unsafe and insecure early attachment relationships the growing body-brain is fed the information that the world AS A WHOLE is not a good, healthy place to attach within or to!  Epigenetic changes then happen and development is correspondingly altered.  Our DNA code is told about these difficult conditions by our genetic ‘middle people’ – and VOILA!  Changes happen that are as difficult to live with as was the original environment that caused them to happen in the first place.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++

Discovering what the range of these changes is can be done either through what we call ‘diagnosis’ or through what we call ‘assessment’.  In the end, we are talking about the same process of identifying what was WRONG in the earliest attach-to-the-world environment that led to these changes happening in the first place.

But we cannot POSSIBLY talk about either ‘diagnosing’ or ‘assessing’ any individual person while we separate their difficulties from the environment that influenced the entire development of all aspects of their body from the start.

++++++++++++++++++++

+DISSOCIATIVE IDENTITY DISORDER HAPPENS FOR FAMILIES!

+++++++++++++++++++++++

I went outside to work on my adobe landscaping project after I finished my last post, but here I am back again to capture my next sequence of thoughts:  A family can have a Dissociative Identity Disorder just like an individual person can.

Duh!  That makes perfect sense to me now that I noticed this!  I was thinking outside that if good ‘ole Newton had had to rely on a piece of a seed falling out of an ant’s mouth and hitting the ground to come up with his theory about gravity rather than relying on an apple falling off of the branch of a tree, maybe none of us today would quite understand what keeps us stuck into our shoes other than our laces (or velcro).

It’s no less true that the same forces that bring an ant’s lost scrap of food down to earth is the same force that dropped the apple, but without being able to witness a process within the format of a bigger picture, things can be easy to miss.

My story, my mother’s story, my family’s story is an extreme one.  Therefore it perhaps offers the opportunity to discover something that might happen within many families but is just as easy to miss as the ant’s dropped fleck.

Anyone who ends up in adulthood with an insecure attachment disorder due to inadequate good caregiver interactions from birth forward during critical stages of development simply ‘catches the ball’ that was passed to it by its caregivers and carries that ball forward.

It makes sense to me to say that NOBODY who suffers from major dissociational problems in their adult life could help but ‘catch’ those dissociational patterns from their parents just like offspring can catch AIDS or any of us can catch a contagious disease.

Therefore, if we consider Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) within the larger context, we will know without a doubt that the dis-order came from being raised in a family that ALSO had Dissociative Identity Disorder.

In a culture hep on believing that everyone is born ‘equal’ and therefore equally autonomous, we need to remember that being a fully healthy autonomous person ONLY happens if adequate safe and secure attachment interactions were available to build a truly healthy autonomous body-nervous system-brain-mind-self from the start of life.

It the safe and secure attachment requirements were not met a fully healthy and autonomous person will not be the end result.  Lack of autonomy goes right along with an insecure attachment disorder because they are essentially the exact same thing.

Without the development of autonomy (for reasons just stated) an individual will NOT have a stable, healthy, balanced, fully formed and benevolently functioning IDENTITY.

Humans are not designed in the biological factory of life to hatch from an egg.  We are designed to manifest our genetic potential interactively with the environment we are born into and formed by.  Ours is an adaptive, flexible, and highly purposeful design.  This design is the reason our species is still here.

Our developmental process – which continues to happen during every millisecond of our lifetime in our body as our genetic code continues to form us – happens through feedforward and feedbackward information loops.  If a major piece of information we receive and process is about a malevolent environment, we have no choice in our beginnings but to form our body in adaptation to these malevolent conditions.

That my mother was formed within an environment that was not benevolent enough and was too malevolent so that she formed an insecure attachment disorder meant that she was destined — without intervention or healing — to pass it onto her offspring.  Her attachment disorder included major dissociation due to the malevolent environment she was formed in.

My father also suffered from certain conditions from his birth that created his body-brain-mind-self to be less than autonomous, which made him a perfect match for my mother.  They meshed, enmeshed, and became ‘one person’ as their summer 1957 letters so clearly describe.  They formed a secondary identity based on their mutual interdependence on one another BECAUSE they lacked true safe and secure attachment within their own self.

This secondary identity could ASSUME the ‘outfits’ (like a wardrobe of clothing) of identity from external environmental influences that were NOT representative of WHO each of these persons COULD HAVE BEEN if they each had been raised within a safe and securely attached early environment  or of who they actually were (or could have been).

++++

This led me to thinking about what a challenge healing and positive change can be for a family just like it can be for an individual.  If the family is made up of insecurely attached people who have no fully formed healthy autonomous identity as separate individuals, the family will have a secondary identity that might as well BE not only the family but the individuals within it.

Family Dissociative Identity Disorder would mean that whatever systems are operating within the family, whatever patterns, actually ARE the family because there is no other autonomous identity present.  It would be not only extremely disorganizing and disorienting for a family to attempt to alter their family DID but also could be a nearly impossible goal if the autonomy of the individual members is not IMPROVED first.

This means to me that addressing the patterns of individual people’s insecure attachment within a family becomes the only reasonable first step that will be effective.  Every other change that is attempted will actually be just a continuation of ‘let’s assume another identity like a new suit of clothes’ patterns and will actually build up and add to the DID problems rather than offer the start of a solution.

++++

If I am correct, and in looking at the extreme picture of my family I think that I am, any so-called therapy or treatment offered to any member of a family that does not address the lack of autonomy that an unsafe and insecure attachment as the body-brain formed FIRST is actually supporting the Dissociative Identity Disorder of the family because it is feeding it.

Trying to insert ‘recovery’ into a family as if it is an outfit they can add to their repertoire of ‘things to wear’ is NOT addressing the core problem of the insecure attachment patterns within every family members body-brain that WILL be there to some extent.  The only alternative for any individual family member’s health and well-being happens ONLY if and when there is some safe and securely attached (and attachable-to) person in their life.  This is the number ONE resiliency factor.

Outside people (external resources) trying to assist a family to heal are not being representatives of safe and secure attachment if they are feeding the DID within the family rather than offering autonomous support based on the core facts of what caused a family to become so ‘sick’ in the first place and what will truly help them to heal.

+++++++++++++++++++++++

From Kristalyn Salters-Pedneault, PhD, your Guide to Borderline Personality Disorder Have trouble articulating who you are, or what you like? Do you find yourself conforming to whatever others in your current setting want you to be, with no real anchor? This week, learn more about identity issues in BPD.

Who Am I? BPD and Identity
Plenty of people without BPD struggle with identity issues, too. But people with BPD often have a very profound lack of sense of self.
Finding Meaning – The First Steps Toward Identity
If you struggle with your identity, you may wonder if there is anything you can do to “find yourself.” There are some things that can help you down the path– finding meaningful moments in your life can get you there.
Does Impulsive Behavior Interfere With Identity Formation?
Some clinicians believe that people with BPD struggle with identity issues because their behavior is so impulsive they have trouble defining “who they are” through their behaviors (which can be erratic and unpredictable). Learn more about impulsive behavior in BPD.
For Family and Friends of Individuals with BPD
Does someone you care about have BPD? BPD can affect all types of relationships, including friends, family members, and romantic partners. Learn more about how BPD may be affecting your relationship, how to cope when a loved one has BPD, and how you can help.

Must Reads

What is BPD?
Symptoms of BPD
Diagnosis of BPD
Treatment of BPD
Living with BPD

+++++++++++++++++++++++

+AUGUST 1957 – OUR FAMILY’S DISSOCIATION

++++++++++++++++++++

I am still hard at work on the seemingly unending job of transcribing the rest of my mother’s letters.  A title for the book coming out of this collection might be:  Mildred’s Romance with Alaska:  A Homesteading Adventure in Letters.

Here is a short section from the first letter my mother wrote once she arrived in her ‘Promised Land’.  “Transported’ is the word my mother used to describe how her traveling experience felt to her.  Many people know what the experience of rapid travel over great distances to a different place feels like.

What I find so interesting, having just worked my way through the nearly 80,000 words that transpired between my parents in their letters before my mother’s arrival in Alaska is that once she arrived THERE everything seemed to change right along with the change in place, the migration, that had happened for my family.

Reading my mother’s June and July 1957 letters, and then beginning to read her August 1957 letters if I didn’t KNOW the connection I would think an entirely different person was now writing.  Yet because I was a member of this family I know that nothing had REALLY changed – not my mother, not my father, and not our closed-door family dynamics.

++++++++++++++++++++

August 1, 1957 Thursday – Eagle River, Alaska

Dearest Mother (Charles and Carolyn)

It’s really hard to believe I am actually in Alaska!  I feel as if I were transported here on the Magic Carpet in Grandma’s stories she told when I was a little girl.

Airplane travel is certainly wonderful – I arrived in Anchorage at 10:45 yesterday morning – a half hour before scheduled, so Bill wasn’t there to greet us.

Really, Mom it was the most thrilling, exciting thing that has ever happened to me.  The trip here was all worth it just to have flown!  I could write you pages and pages just telling you about the flight but there’s so much I have to tell you.  I am bursting with news….

The children loved it, were as calm as could be.  I am still recovering.  It was a thrill, but also quite terrifying to climb 20,000 feet.  John ‘s nose was pressed to the window every minute!  (when he wasn’t sleeping).  Oh Mom, I am so anxious now for you to experience all I have – I know you’d be a wonderful traveler.  On the Northwest Orient Flight there were two Grandmothers coming up to see their daughters who had also migrated to Alaska.  One was in her 80s and the other about your age, was joining her daughter and family for a three week vacation – camping trip.  It was their third visit a piece!!!

(bold type is mine]

++++++++++++++++++++

And yet I wonder if the PLACE of suburban southern California had little to offer in terms of emotional resources for my family, especially for my mother, while Alaska did have something to offer her.

++

Mother wrote this on a scrap of paper on the same August first day she wrote her first letter to her mother:

Second day in Alaska

We always have wild flowers on our table, picked by anxious to please tiny hands.  What greater pleasure is there then to watch small children discovering the wonder of nature in the woods – streams to watch flow, questions to answer – where does the water come from and where does it go, will it ever dry up?

Mommy are these berries good to eat?  Will this water really freeze and will we really have snow?  Yes, darling, yes darling and isn’t it a bit of heaven for us right here in the woodland and don’t you feel closer to God here as I do?  Yes, Mommy, yes and so our life in Alaska begins.

A Bit of Heaven In the Woods –

++

Always” here is obviously a relative term because we had only been in Alaska one single full day.  Mother’s use of this word ‘always’ is like a peep-hole to me through which I can watch in her writings the changes in attitude, mood, feelings, thoughts and hopes that my mother now expresses in her letters at the same time nothing has REALLY changed at all.

Insecure attachments caused my very early neglect, abuse, maltreatment and trauma – as these experiences form and change an infant-child’s growing body-brain, often include an altered experience of time.  Those altered time perceptions are part of what attachment experts can detect through their assessment tool, the Adult Attachment Interview because it is in the telling of one’s life story that these time alterations appear as they represent the underlying incoherency that trauma creates not only in a survivor’s story, but also as that incoherency has built the survivor’s body-brain.

++

When I think about dissociation, I think about these altered perceptions of time and the changes in processing information regarding a person in their own life as time passes.  The second sentence my mother wrote in her August first letter makes a direct connection back to her very early childhood when her grandmother came to live in her home with her mother after her parents had divorced and her grandfather had died.

A magic carpet ride.  Being transported in time and space.  Dissociation does this as it ‘magically’ connects experiences from the past to ongoing experience in the present moment.  This connection process is always happening for everyone, but it is for those whose infant-childhoods did not pave a smooth, continuous highway of experience — because the breaks trauma and maltreatment created in their ongoing experience of life did not allow the connections to be made in the body-brain of the survivor in a smooth and continuous way — that dissociation enters the patterns of their thinking, feeling and actions.

Both of my parents chose to create a nearly complete ‘dissociation’ between the experiences of their past in Los Angeles’ suburbia and their new life as migrants to Alaska.  The reality of suburban living that they had previously organized and oriented their lives around disappeared.  They had virtually pulled the plug on most aspects related to their lives.  All the letters following the first of August 1957 include the new organizing and orienting PLACE of Alaska.

Yet for all the opportunities that this new place offered to my parents nothing within the dynamics of our family ACTUALLY changed.  There were just a multitude of different experiences that fed the same people that brought themselves to this new and different place.  My parents created a major dissociation between their old life and their new one, but all the patterns of body-brain-mind-self dissociations that had ALWAYS been inside of the individuals who transported themselves ‘on a magic carpet’ to America’s last frontier were still there.

++

As I think about what my parents DID when they moved to Alaska, no matter what their conscious intentions might have been, I realize that at the same time my parents carried their own inner woundedness right on up to Alaska with them, they were at least amputating themselves and their family from the very real pollution and toxicity of life in the Los Angeles area.

If a wound has become so infected that gangrene sets in and beings to eat up all the healthy tissue surrounding the wound (not unlike how cancer metastasizes), and if the wound itself is not healing, the best move possible is to at least address the problems the gangrene is causing so that life can at least continue on.

When my parents amputated their lives from southern California and transported themselves and their children in a migration to the purity of the north land of Alaska, they took a good step in the rupture-and-repair process that IS healing itself.  In that place, from the moment of their arrival, a new definition of identity began.  The Alaskan Lloyds were born.  This identity was soon even further clarified, solidified and defined as we ‘became’ the Alaskan Homesteading Lloyds.

Yes, we traveled a long, long way from being the Los Angeles southern California suburbanite Lloyds.  Because my mother’s Borderline illness was never identified or healed, all we really accomplished was staying alive – not healing.  But this was certainly a giant step in the right direction and I don’t even want to think what the alternative could have been had our family stayed ‘down south’.

+++++++++++++++++++++

+HAVING A VERY BAD TIME – MOTHER’S 1957 LETTER

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++

By the time my mother reached a month and a half of being in Los Angeles with my father in Alaska, my mother was at the end of her rope.  As I transcribed this letter this morning I can see that ANYONE would have been feeling the way that she was.

Unfortunately, all four of her children paid a price right along with her.  I can tell things had deteriorated and were REALLY bad for her to be ‘spanking’ her precious 2-year-old baby and her beloved 4-year-old – right along with me (nearly 6).  My parents should not EVER have taken on their ‘Alaskan adventure’ with absolutely NO resources.  My father headed to Alaska on the Army’s expense and had to wait for his paychecks to come in before he could even rent a house for his family to join him.

My mother, as she describes in this letter, was broke.  She had no car or home, and was staying at her mother’s house.  My parents had counted on a large check to arrive from my father’s Los Angeles place of employment that was SUPPOSED to have arrived no later than mid-June.  Here it is nearing the end of July and the check was still missing.

These were stressing and distressing times for our family.  It seems strange to find myself empathizing with my mother as I read these letters — placing in context her stated ‘spanking’ of her children.  One BIG problem with my mother’s version of spanking is that she always ‘lost control of her rage’ while she pounded on her children.  She was a big and powerful woman.  Her children were very small.  Her ‘spankings’ were beatings.

Although her violence was usually reserved for me as her chosen target, it is clear from this letter that this period of time was one in which all of her children were ‘fair game’ (though she does not specifically mention here ‘spanking’ my brother).

My mother was still waiting for Army orders that would allow her to take us to my father, but the house he had rented was not available for occupancy until the first of August.  As far as I can tell there are six more letters remaining to be transcribed that cover what happened up until the time we actually left California – and not one of them is from my father.  I have a feeling that at some point my mother destroyed them.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++

July 25, 1957 postmark – California

Dear Bill,

I just got home from a ride to Fontana to get your letter.  I received yours telling me about it the day I left Crestline but knew it couldn’t have reached Fontana on Friday (?) so thought I’d call and have it forwarded.  Only they must have a signed request to forward mail so all the children and I went there today.

I am not going to pretend we’re enjoying ourselves now – we’re not.

Bill I tried so hard – believe me and I think I succeeded in keeping them happy in Glendora but ever since I joined Mother I’ve been plain miserable.  It isn’t all her fault – we just can’t be together constantly and live together.  I always knew it was an impossibility.  You can love a person and still not be able to live with them.

Now, today, the children have been TERRIBLE.  Tonight both Cindy and Linda were spanked and put to bed when we got home.  I tell you everything is haywire.  If only we could’ve left before – – – .  Cindy has constantly misbehaved and was so good all summer.  Grandma just doesn’t get along with her and now openly admits it.  Cindy and Linda had a grand time together and now fight constantly.  John hasn’t any toys or anyone to play with.  Sharon has been spanked twice (hard).  She’s more spoiled and fresh every day.  I try to forgive and overlook but I can’t any longer.  Tonight Cindy cried herself to sleep.

We’re all miserable.  You see if Mother was relaxed and a homebody and we could find peace here it would be different but as it is – well, it’s terrible and Mother can’t get her work done.

People call constantly for reports and she’s upset by all this too.  That’s why I took all the children today but they’re tired of travelling [sic], tired of sitting and being quiet.  Linda and Cindy haven’t been out-doors all summer and now even their dolls and toys are packed.

I tell you this is it!

I’ve inquired at Motels and can’t afford it!  I have no linens, no car, no money.  I am broke, Bill, broke.  Today you sent me 75.00.  I owe Mother so much $ it isn’t even funny.  The last 10 she gave me I paid 7.00 out of it to Parent’s Magazine or would’ve had to pay them full.  I got a notice your Life Insurance has expired – two payments are due.  Out of the $ you sent me I had – *Important – to pay Mayflower cash for these checks – you sign them and return them to me and I have to bring them back to Glendora for the money.  So return them immediately please.  Both signed!!!

The $140 I had to return – Bill that large check better come.

I agree with everything you said in your letter.  I will not buy a car.  I will fly and have made all inquiries – everything set – all I need (I checked with Miss Davies or son today at MacArthur- is [the Army] orders.  Bill she says they figure 30 days for furniture – I can’t wait.  I tell you I am coming as soon as I get the money and orders.  If I can’t come to Anchorage I’ll go to Seattle and wait there – I must get out of here.  If I stay at a Motel here Mom will feel awful so I’ll at least come to Seattle and wait there.

You said your letter was mixed up – well so is this but it’s 9:45 and I haven’t had any dinner.

I am more upset every day.

Mother is at her wit’s end.

The kids have been good, patient and sweet through all this and it hasn’t been fair to them and now they too, without knowing it, are fed up!  And I am not patient any more.  I too am tired —.

Besides missing you so I think I’ll die, I’ve been constantly in a state over money – as usual.  I can’t be independent and still constantly ask Mother for money.  It as usual, gives her the feeling of a Matyr [sic], “After all I do for you,” the right to tell me what to do and interfere with the children.

It’s all wrong – we were wrong many years ago and I have paid and paid and paid and I am still paying!  [lots of underlines here].  To have bought a new car would have been all wrong.  I want to be independent and leave here and I want a new car for us (but I’ll wait).  The only way to be really independent and proud again is to pay our bills off and stand on our feet again!

But meanwhile all of these things exist –

Must I spank the kids for 30 days now, fight with my brother and Mother – bear up with a smiling face while I wait – I can’t.

I am all alone, Bill – I need you – I must come to you – I can’t wait.

Bill, Bill, Bill.

Please, you haven’t explained your money situation to me.  I know nothing.  Last pay day I had the car money but paid it all out – I sent you the list – I’ll check later but I paid Edison about 50, the water, gas, Tolleson, McMahans, Sears, New York Live etc.  – Bill  I wondered if you had enough to pay the two months rent – you only sent me a small amount.

I thought this pay-day — I counted on at least 150.  Why, I have to eat, pay all those payments – especially Budget, Milk, and Phone – – – etc. – – – until I receive the large check.

Did you pay some of the rent out of the check?  Enlighten me and I’ll send you a list of what I owe Mother and what I’ve spent.

Today, for instance, I had to by shoes for Baby, Linda, Cindy and John.  Theirs were gone, really gone and so is my money.

Return these small checks and the 140 and tell me when I can expect more.  I realize now that my night letter last night is hopeless – but Bill as soon as the orders arrive can I come.  Must I wait until the furniture arrives to start?

The woman today said you have to authorize the furniture to leave, you may have already, but just in case she’ll send to me and I’ll send to you – papers to sign – and you return them to me.

– – –  Hum-m.

Long involved procedures – do they ever end?

I had to laugh a saleslady I’d known before said today “Well, you’re staying at your Mother’s – isn’t  that nice that you have your mother to take good care of you.”  I almost spit in her eye.

Oh Bill – I missed you terribly in Glendora but inside I felt good, right about things and now I feel mean to everyone.  All this business and strain here has finally told.  We all feel it.

Do you realize I haven’t been away from the children once (except for quick business) since you’ve left.  You don’t have that strain and it’s a strain, believe me!

We all feel it.

Bill tonight I’m not going to answer your letters – I am too weary and I’m too full of all this other.  It breaks me to have to be mad at the children and I don’t know what to do with them.  As I said before everything is gone to storage – I had no choice and the rest I take over tomorrow.  I figure it might leave Thursday or Friday and I have 2 or 3 more loads, which means trips and I have no idea how to get those trunks over there (loaded) and no $ to pay anyone to do it.  [Linda note:  These were the large wooden old steamer trunks.]

After I paid market $10 I had 65 – 3 pairs of shoes at 4.00 per pair = 12, 53 left (not even enough to pay Budget).

Please answer all this immediately.

Oh Bill I need you so!

As I figure last pay day you received 200.00 and gave me 50 leaving only 150.00.  Then you had to pay 304.00.  So from this pay-day you must’ve used another 150 for the rent.  Is that right and how much do you have now – enough to get by on, I hope, until that cused [sic] $ arrives from Water and Power.  [Linda note:  They were still waiting for the check to arrive for my father’s unused vacation when he left his job there with the city of Los Angeles.]

But you can understand I haven’t spent any money on recreation – it only cost 1.50 or 2.00 to go to the lake once and only about 1.50 for a movie yesterday.  All the rest has been living expenses.  I’ve paid bills with all our money and some of Mother’s and borrowed alot from her.  [letter ends here]

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++

<!–[if !mso]> <! st1\:*{behavior:url(#ieooui) } –>

++++

July 25, 1957 postmark – California

Dear Bill,

I just got home from a ride to Fontana to get your letter.  I received yours telling me about it the day I left Crestline but knew it couldn’t have reached Fontana on Friday (?) so thought I’d call and have it forwarded.  Only they must have a signed request to forward mail so all the children and I went there today.

I am not going to pretend we’re enjoying ourselves now – we’re not.

Bill I tried so hard – believe me and I think I succeeded in keeping them happy in Glendora but ever since I joined Mother I’ve been plain miserable.  It isn’t all her fault – we just can’t be together constantly and live together.  I always knew it was an impossibility.  You can love a person and still not be able to live with them.

Now, today, the children have been TERRIBLE.  Tonight both Cindy and Linda were spanked and put to bed when we got home.  I tell you everything is haywire.  If only we could’ve left before – – – .  Cindy has constantly misbehaved and was so good all summer.  Grandma just doesn’t get along with her and now openly admits it.  Cindy and Linda had a grand time together and now fight constantly.  John hasn’t any toys or anyone to play with. Sharon has been spanked twice (hard).  She’s more spoiled and fresh every day.  I try to forgive and overlook but I can’t any longer.  Tonight Cindy cried herself to sleep.

We’re all miserable.  You see if Mother was relaxed and a homebody and we could find peace here it would be different but as it is – well, it’s terrible and Mother can’t get her work done.

People call constantly for reports and she’s upset by all this too.  That’s why I took all the children today but they’re tired of travelling [sic], tired of sitting and being quiet.  Linda and Cindy haven’t been out-doors all summer and now even their dolls and toys are packed.

I tell you this is it!

I’ve inquired at Motels and can’t afford it!  I have no linens, no car, no money.  I am broke, Bill, broke.  Today you sent me 75.00.  I owe Mother so much $ it isn’t even funny.  The last 10 she gave me I paid 7.00 out of it to Parent’s Magazine or would’ve had to pay them full.  I got a notice your Life Insurance has expired – two payments are due.  Out of the $ you sent me I had – *Important – to pay Mayflower cash for these checks – you sign them and return them to me and I have to bring them back to Glendora for the money.  So return them immediately please.  Both signed!!!

The $140 I had to return – Bill that large check better come.

I agree with everything you said in your letter.  I will not buy a car.  I will fly and have made all inquiries – everything set – all I need (I checked with Miss Davies or son today at MacArthur- is [the Army] orders.  Bill she says they figure 30 days for furniture – I can’t wait.  I tell you I am coming as soon as I get the money and orders.  If I can’t come to Anchorage I’ll go to Seattle and wait there – I must get out of here.  If I stay at a Motel here Mom will feel awful so I’ll at least come to Seattle and wait there.

You said your letter was mixed up – well so is this but it’s 9:45 and I haven’t had any dinner.

I am more upset every day.

Mother is at her wit’s end.

The kids have been good, patient and sweet through all this and it hasn’t been fair to them and now they too, without knowing it, are fed up!  And I am not patient any more.  I too am tired —.

Besides missing you so I think I’ll die, I’ve been constantly in a state over money – as usual.  I can’t be independent and still constantly ask Mother for money.  It as usual, gives her the feeling of a Matyr [sic], “After all I do for you,” the right to tell me what to do and interfere with the children.

It’s all wrong – we were wrong many years ago and I have paid and paid and paid and I am still paying!  [lots of underlines here].  To have bought a new car would have been all wrong.  I want to be independent and leave here and I want a new car for us (but I’ll wait).  The only way to be really independent and proud again is to pay our bills off and stand on our feet again!

But meanwhile all of these things exist –

Must I spank the kids for 30 days now, fight with my brother and Mother – bear up with a smiling face while I wait – I can’t.

I am all alone, Bill – I need you – I must come to you – I can’t wait.

Bill, Bill, Bill.

Please, you haven’t explained your money situation to me.  I know nothing.  Last pay day I had the car money but paid it all out – I sent you the list – I’ll check later but I paid Edison about 50, the water, gas, Tolleson, McMahans, Sears, New York Live etc.  – Bill  I wondered if you had enough to pay the two months rent – you only sent me a small amount.

I thought this pay-day — I counted on at least 150.  Why, I have to eat, pay all those payments – especially Budget, Milk, and Phone – – – etc. – – – until I receive the large check.

Did you pay some of the rent out of the check?  Enlighten me and I’ll send you a list of what I owe Mother and what I’ve spent.

Today, for instance, I had to by shoes for Baby, Linda, Cindy and John.  Theirs were gone, really gone and so is my money.

Return these small checks and the 140 and tell me when I can expect more.  I realize now that my night letter last night is hopeless – but Bill as soon as the orders arrive can I come.  Must I wait until the furniture arrives to start?

The woman today said you have to authorize the furniture to leave, you may have already, but just in case she’ll send to me and I’ll send to you – papers to sign – and you return them to me.

– – –  Hum-m.

Long involved procedures – do they ever end?

I had to laugh a saleslady I’d known before said today “Well, you’re staying at your Mother’s – isn’t  that nice that you have your mother to take good care of you.”  I almost spit in her eye.

Oh Bill – I missed you terribly in Glendora but inside I felt good, right about things and now I feel mean to everyone.  All this business and strain here has finally told.  We all feel it.

Do you realize I haven’t been away from the children once (except for quick business) since you’ve left.  You don’t have that strain and it’s a strain, believe me!

We all feel it.

Bill tonight I’m not going to answer your letters – I am too weary and I’m too full of all this other.  It breaks me to have to be mad at the children and I don’t know what to do with them.  As I said before everything is gone to storage – I had no choice and the rest I take over tomorrow.  I figure it might leave Thursday or Friday and I have 2 or 3 more loads, which means trips and I have no idea how to get those trunks over there (loaded) and no $ to pay anyone to do it.  [Linda note:  These were the large wooden old steamer trunks.]

After I paid market $10 I had 65 – 3 pairs of shoes at 4.00 per pair = 12, 53 left (not even enough to pay Budget).

Please answer all this immediately.

Oh Bill I need you so!

As I figure last pay day you received 200.00 and gave me 50 leaving only 150.00.  Then you had to pay 304.00.  So from this pay-day you must’ve used another 150 for the rent.  Is that right and how much do you have now – enough to get by on, I hope, until that cused [sic] $ arrives from Water and Power.  [Linda note:  They were still waiting for the check to arrive for my father’s unused vacation when he left his job there with the city of Los Angeles.]

But you can understand I haven’t spent any money on recreation – it only cost 1.50 or 2.00 to go to the lake once and only about 1.50 for a movie yesterday.  All the rest has been living expenses.  I’ve paid bills with all our money and some of Mother’s and borrowed alot from her.  [letter ends here]

+CHILD ABUSE: THE POWER OF THE TRUTH AND THE DANGERS OF THE LIES

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++

NOTE:  This post evidently has a formatting life of its own!  I can find no way to change what appears in big bold letters below.  I did not bold this part of this post, nor can I change it!

I do a lot of a different sort of thinking while I am outside spending hours digging dirt, mixing mud and laying adobe bricks in my newly forming walkway.  This morning as I think about this different sort of thinking I realize that I could probably call it ‘Jello thinking’, because that is the image that popped into my mind as I ‘looked inside my body’ to see what happens in this process.

As I have mentioned so many times before, because my body-brain had to form in the midst of ongoing and terrifying trauma, I had to change in my development and now neither my left- nor my right-brain hemispheres operate ‘normally’, nor does the corpus callosum region between them that passes back and forth information that they need to understand together.

(SEE this article for background:  McLean Researchers Document Brain Damage Linked to Child Abuse and Neglect – Release: McLean Hospital, December 14, 2000)

So it takes me much more time to put things together in my thinking, and even then I can never be assured that I end up with the same conclusions that I would have if infant-child abuse had not so changed my body-brain.  But I am left to work with the end result of these changes – who I am today – and I do the best that I can.

Which brings me back to my ‘Jello thinking’ process.  At the same time I am working my way through the transcription of my parents’ 1957 June and July letters to one another, which now includes over 60,000 words and I’m not done yet, I realize that the best thing I could ever hope for is that some day some special person finds these letters and studies them thoroughly with an attachment-informed mind toward the completion of a Doctoral thesis.

I would ask the question of any one of us who has some experience with opening a little rectangular box of Jello, who have ever boiled up water and poured the Jello’s brightly colored crystals into it, stirred them around until they dissolved, and then put the mixture into the refrigerator to cool – returning periodically to stir the mixture to make sure it solidifies without the thick gelatin coating on the top – at what point is the Jello, well, Jello?

Is it Jello in its powdered form?  Is it Jello while it is still soupy?  Or is it only ACTUALLY Jello when it is firm and ready to serve and to eat?

At the same time I would ask, “When is a thought ACTUALLY a thought?  Is it a thought only when it appears with proper grammar, complete in words within a sentence?”  Are the ‘body thoughts’ that I have without words while I am working to transcribe these letters and as I then go work with my hands in the mud ACTUALLY thoughts?  When has a thought ‘Jello-ed up’?

Even though as the daughter of these two people who lived with them for 18 years, and as a person who was nearly six years old at the time they were written, I perhaps SHOULD be able to put my finger on the pulse of what was going on between my parents these 53 years ago, I cannot do it.  I realize as I write this that I can’t ‘put my finger on the pulse’ of what was going on between them because what’s really going on is that there is a terrible gaping wound within BOTH of these people that means that they were both actually bleeding to death.  Would I look for the pulse in their letters while ignoring the fact the fact of their massive, mutual and mortal hemorrhaging?

++

Because I have made an agreement with myself to simply publish the collection of my mother’s letters with their responses intact without censorship or editorial comment, I am attempting to ignore most of my reactions to their words contained in these spewing ‘love letters’ between Mother and Father.  I am saving my reactions for some future date when the letters have been completely transcribed, edited for format and published.  THEN I hope to write my version of this ‘Alaskan homesteading adventure story’ that belongs to my family.

In the meantime there are some glaring topics that appear to me right now.  They are as hard to ignore as someone else’s on-bright headlights as they drive too close to your rear bumper behind you as you drive down a dark highway in the middle of a moonless night.  Those lights are reflecting straight into your eyes, glaring from your rear-view mirror – and you have to do something about it.

Closing your eyes and driving blindly is not a good option.  Do you put on your sunglasses?  Do you flip the switch on your mirror that allows you to dim the reflection?  Do you slap the mirror so it aims the distracting and irritating brilliance anywhere else but into your eyes?  Do you slow down or pull over to the side of the highway, hoping the car behind you will pass so you can watch their red taillights disappear into the distant darkness ahead of you?  Or do you ignore the situation and keep on driving like the lights that belong to the driver behind you don’t even exist?

How much of what my body-brain knows as the truth about what was ACTUALLY going on between my parents in their lives do I pay attention to as I work to transcribe their letters?  I often imagine what readers of my parents’ letters might see in them.  Will they detect the madness?  Will they in their innocence and naivety believe that what they are reading IS ACTUALLY a love story?  Can I leave those readers alone to experience their reading without my added comments about what a totally living hell our home life truly was?

++

I am learning to watch how my brain processes all this information.  My body has very real and powerful FEELING reactions to this work I am doing.  When someone asked me last week why I continue to do this work if it is so difficult and I don’t anticipate getting anything personally helpful out of the process, I told them, “I do this work because I believe it is important for others.  I believe there is something here that will be helpful to somebody else.”

In the meantime my right brain, tied as it intimately is with the nonverbal knowledge of the history in my body of 18 years of abuse from these exact same parents – abuse that was as hidden from the world of words as it remained hidden in the words of their letters – I feel as if I am hanging onto the broken end of a still very hot live electrical high wire.  I am a sort of conduit for the truth about the reality of the damage that a severe Borderline Personality Disorder person can do in their lifetime, particularly to their children (and to their mate).

I am very grateful that I can go outside in the pure desert air, in the sunshine, among the birds and the butterflies that stop to cool their tiny, dainty feet on the newly formed wet mud bricks, and in the midst of the sounds of Mexican life that drift through the air over the dividing borderline between our two countries – and ground out the terrible intensity of the truth about what ACTUALLY happened during my childhood and during the childhood of my siblings.

++++

But before I go out there today to sling my mud and make my bricks there are two things I NEED to mention.  My body, my right brain, my left brain are not going to let me leave this computer screen until I say these two things:

(1)  When my mother first wrote to my father in Alaska that she was going to relinquish the rented house she was staying in as she waited in Los Angeles for him to send for us to join him, and move into her Mother’s house, my father VERY CLEARLY warned her not to do it.  While I am not going to delve into their letters at this moment to find all of the exact words that transpired between them on this topic, I will say that my mother obviously ignored everything that my father had to say on the topic and made the move anyway.

By the time my mother has given up the rented house (which she really HAD to do because there wasn’t any money available to pay the rent), and moved in with her mother, and things went as terribly as my father had told her they would, and by the time my mother writes my father her pitiful and desperate sob story about how terrible things were indeed going at her mother’s, my father simply responds back to her by saying in his July 24, 1957 letter:

I hate your family for making things so miserable for you!  Only a few days left, why couldn’t they let you leave in peace?

I have the letter you wrote Sunday night, and it’s heartbreaking to read.  I can sense the way you felt, and I know what a horrible time you’ve been having.  I feel so responsible for letting you in for all this.  It seems as though I should have been able to prevent it somehow.”

He then concludes this letter with this:

Oh Mildred I love you, love you, love you! X X X X X Hurry to me now as fast as you can darling – I love and wait only for you.

Your Adoring Husband, Bill

He didn’t say “I told you so.”  Did he think that?  Did he even remember he’d warned her?  Did he wonder at all at her decision to ignore his warning and move in with her mother in spite of them?  Nor does he seem to have taken any kind of an objective stance so that he could question whether or not what my mother was describing ACTUALLY happened that way or not.  He doesn’t indicate that perhaps his wife caused the difficulties to erupt with her mother.  He simply unequivocally believes her and supports her in her reported version of reality.

++++

By body-brain put the information just presented above in (1) with this information:

(2)  I have retained intact a memory from this time period before my 6th birthday that has never changed.  In this memory we arrive at this mountain resort cabin my mother is writing from with my beloved 14-month-older brother carefully carrying his beloved turtle, Timothy inside a Chinese food take-out container.  John was terribly worried about the affect the hot summer’s day was having on his pet.  In my memory I am walking right behind John as he enters the cabin, locates the kitchen, stands in front of the refrigerator, opens the door of the freezer as he continues to talk to Timothy.

I understood what my brother, who had just turned 7 was doing and why.  He put the little container with Timothy in it into the freezer to cool him off.

I also remember John’s horror upon discovering he had forgotten Timothy in the freezer.  In my memory I am again standing very close to John as he opens the freezer, removes the container, opens the top, and finds his beloved pet frozen inside a block of ice.  I remember his heartbroken tears.

While John has no memory 53 years later of the turtle, let alone of what happened to the turtle, I have NEVER forgotten my memory of it.  So when I read the following words last night in my mother’s July 15, 1957 Monday letter, I went into a form of ‘memory shock’.

I drove to the town and lake this morning, poor Mother got sick after breakfast and had to go to a gas station and when we returned we found John’s turtle dead from the heat yesterday.  He broke down completely and cried and cried.  I tell you it’s been awful.”

I am still processing the confusion I feel over the conflicting accounts – mine and now my mother’s – about the death of Timothy.

First of all, she rented this mountain cabin beginning on Saturday July 13th and I would expect that this Saturday is the day that we drove through the heat to the mountain.  If my memory was accurate, the turtle would have been placed by my brother in the freezer on the Saturday when we first arrived at the cabin.  My mother is writing on a Monday and is referring to Sunday’s heat as being the contributor to the demise of John’s beloved turtle who died according to her version of the story on Monday.

This state of inner confusion that I feel about these conflicting accounts is typical of what happens to me most of the time when I try to find my own version of reality and hold onto it in the face of my mother’s version of reality.  Working my way around and through this tiny turtle story is significantly important for me to do.

Second of all, a turtle is (DUH!) a reptile.  It cannot regulate its own body temperature.  If a turtle gets too hot, hot enough that its life is endangered it does not wait a day or two to have its fatal reaction.  It simply DIES when the overheating happens.

This is an extremely important turning point inside my own being about how my mother’s version of reality SELDOM matched the truth!  It is also an extremely important example of how subtly, thoroughly and effectively she was ALWAYS able to manipulate everyone else’s version of reality so that it matched her own.

I hold onto this FACT as if it is a life preserver thrown to me as I sink below the surface of deadly waters:  An overheated turtle does not wait to die.

Therefore, without my having to suspect MYSELF I can tell immediately within my mother’s letter that there is something fishy about her story.

This FACT helps me gain my own footing about my own memory of what happened.  For some reason, perhaps because he was a little boy, perhaps because of my mother’s continual creation of strange excitement that sucked everyone around her into her chaotic storms, perhaps because my brother was distracted by being in this foreign environment with grandmother present, and everything that was going on around him – another FACT of the matter seemed to be that John simply forgot his turtle in the freezer from late Saturday until sometime Monday.

If I give myself permission to believe my own self rather than believe my mother’s version of this story, I can learn right here, within this single, tiny, nearly insignificant (in the grand drama of our family’s life) event of the death of my brother’s turtle how expertly my mother’s created her twisted version of stories that she would tell my father.

++++

This is an example of the insidious way my mother controlled her family – ALL of us, including her own mother when it suited her.  (See post:  +A WORD ABOUT INSIDIOUS INFANT-CHILD ABUSE.)

I believe that there is AN EXTREMELY, CRITICALLY IMPORTANT POINT here.  This is an example of what MANY severe infant-child abuse survivors experienced when they were little.  It is an example of how difficult it is for we survivors to EVER BE ABLE TO VALIDATE OUR OWN REALITY in the face of the twisted, distorted, unbelievably destructive nature of living with ANY ABUSIVE BORDERLINE PARENT!

When people ask me why I continue this nasty work on my forensic autobiography even though it is ‘upsetting’, and I tell them there is something in this work that MATTERS to other survivors, these two examples are proof to me that I am right.

It NEVER mattered what the seed of an event ACTUALLY was, whether my mother was communicating about her terrible feelings within her relationship with her own mother or the death of the turtle that was so loved by her little son.  At the center of EVERYTHING that my mother touched was her Borderline Personality Disorder.

My mother was a MASTER manipulator of the truth.  She was a MASTER manipulator of all information about what happened within her family.  In the same way that my mother was expertly able to manipulate what my father knew about her fight with her mother or the death of John’s turtle, she also expertly manipulated what my father KNEW about me.

At the same time my father was present and KNEW about many of the terrible things my mother did to me he NEVER ONCE ‘interfered’ to stop her or to protect me in any way.  What last night’s lightning bolt of insight hit me with and triggered deep within my entire being by these two statements between my parents I am citing here today, was the realization that my father existed within my mother’s Borderline world and no other.

My father was my mother’s SAP, and everything about their relationship MEANT that exactly what happened TO ME – HAPPENED.

++++

Did my mother consciously KNOW and CHOOSE to distort and twist the story she told my father about the turtle?  Did she consciously KNOW and CHOOSE to distort and twist the story she told my father about ‘the fight’ she had with her mother?

What possible REASON might my mother have had to LIE to my father about the turtle’s death?  Was she afraid the truth would have implicated HER in some way?  Was she afraid that admitting the truth of her young son’s FORGETTING about his precious turtle in the freezer would somehow make her husband think badly of his – HER son – so that his view of HER through the actions of HER son would somehow reflect back BADLY on her?

The truth is that this entire topic is sickening.  That the underlying reality this topic addresses consumed my entire 18-year childhood (and that of my siblings) and hence changed our entire physiological development body-brain-mind-self and hence the entire quality of the lifetime of all of us, MATTERS!

It also MATTERS to me that nobody who has not lived with a severely abusive Borderline parent cannot even BEGIN to imagine what we endured and what we have survived.  Nor can these other people BEGIN to imagine how the madness of such a parent permeated everything we experienced not only when we were little, but also for the rest of our lives.

It is nearly impossible to disentangle THE TRUTH, let alone OUR TRUTH, from the all-encompassing, all-pervasive MENTAL MANIPULATIONS that accompany severe infant-child abuse by a severe Borderline parent.  To be able to actually find the truth means that we have to be able to detect the lies.

This lie-truth detection process is about as impossible to accomplish as it would be to consciously detect and then choose which air molecules we are going to breath before we inhale them.

Yet we survivors cannot give up on our task of sorting out the fiction of the lie from the truth of reality, no matter how difficult the job may be.  As I examine the forensic evidence bequeathed to me by my decade-dead parents, I am performing an effort that is beyond microscopic.

I am looking for the truth that exists in the WORDS THAT WERE NEVER WRITTEN in the same way that they WERE NEVER SPOKEN by either one of my parents (or by my grandmother than I know of).

This forensic level of work to claim MY REALITY out of the complete and total wreckage of my childhood is happening on the equivalent level that DNA forensic validation happens in today’s criminal investigations.

What I am learning that is valuable and useful to my own self-betterment and healing is that ANY TIME I experience even a shadow of a doubt, a glimmer of a glance of a doubt, a shimmer of a reflection of a doubt about how MY OWN VERSION of reality differs from the one created and presented by my mother AND BY MY FATHER – I NEED TO KNOW THAT MY VERSION IS RIGHT BECAUSE IT IS TRUE.

At this instant as I write these words I realize that THERE IS a way to make the invisible Borderline visible:  That invisible Borderline is defined by DOUBT.  Wherever, whenever, however I detect ANY DOUBT WHATSOEVER within my body as it relates to any experience I ever had with my parents, that DOUBT defines and makes visible the undefined and invisible Borderline.

Being able to recognize my feeling and even tiny SENSES of doubt allows me to bring the invisible Borderline into visible existence.  My father did not doubt my mother.  In the two examples presented here my father did not doubt my mother’s story about ‘the fight’ with her mother just as he did not doubt my mother’s story about the death of my brother’s turtle.

My father never doubted my mother’s version of ME, either.  Yesterday as I made mud and slung it around I thought about the only time in my life my father telephoned me.  That was in the winter of 1986.  He followed that call with the only visit he ever made to see me and my children.  Looking back on that visit yesterday I realized that he was as completely a representative THEN of my mother’s ‘version of Linda’ as he had been from the moment I was born.

I didn’t recognize my doubts in 1986, so I could not stand up for myself or against his version of reality with my own version of reality.  Yesterday I knew that if I had known in 1986 what I know at this moment, that visit with my father would have gone in an entirely different – and for me healing – direction.

Both of my parents’ words exist on these pieces of paper they wrote them down on over 50 years ago.  I recognize the powerful gift they provide not only to me, but to anyone who considers them in the light of the Borderline reality they represent.  Although I plan to publish their writings as they were written, I also plan to follow their publication with my OWN version of what these letters contain – because they DON’T contain anything about THE TRUTH.

My sister recently took her two grand daughters to a WWII museum in Albuquerque, New Mexico that has sanitized the exhibition by erasing ALL MENTION of the holocaust.  ALL OF IT!  I will not, in the end, be a contributor to that kind of deceptive, dangerous madness!

I will tell MY story.  What I am working up to is being able to tell MY story without any doubts within myself that MY story is how things actually happened and that my parents were, within both of their lifetimes, unredeemable liars.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++

+A WORD ABOUT INSIDIOUS INFANT-CHILD ABUSE

++++++++++++++++++

Before I take my friend’s eleven-year-old Chihuahua to the vet, I have something to say about this three-word combination echoing in my thoughts this morning:  INSIDIOUS CHILD ABUSE.

One thing that I know about insidious child abuse is that it does not have a beginning, a middle or an end.  Insidious abuse has always been there, is always there, will always be there.  For this reason, if not for any other, insidious child abuse remains undetected because it operates the way it does because its insidiousness makes it undetectable.

Turning to Webster’s online dictionary I find:

INSIDIOUS

Etymology: Latin insidiosus, from insidiae ambush, from insidēre to sit in, sit on, from in- + sedēre to sit — more at sit

Date: 1545

1 a : awaiting a chance to entrap : treacherous b : harmful but enticing : seductive <insidious drugs>
2 a : having a gradual and cumulative effect : subtle <the insidious pressures of modern life> b of a disease : developing so gradually as to be well established before becoming apparent

++

What is more enticing to a child from birth but to receive the affection of its caregivers?  In cases where mental illness that leads to infant-child abuse exists from the time an infant-child is born, the caregiver SITS with a trap baited with the hope of affection that the innocent little one is biologically destined to be caught by.

SITTING in wait to trap one’s prey is not a natural state for a mother to be in.  Obviously when this is the set-up, there is something terribly wrong.  The last possible person to detect the existence of the trap is the victim.

Infants and children who are born to Borderline mothers such as mine was are ambushed from the start and ambushed every single step of their way through infancy and childhood.

Part of what brought these thoughts into my head this morning relates to the post I wrote this weekend – +EXAMPLE OF MY MOTHER’S BORDERLINE ‘GOOD VERSUS BAD THINKING’

Not only could I not expect any version of natural mothering response if I ever was sick as a child, I could not express my SELF in misery, either.  I was doomed, ambushed, trapped in insidious abuse I did not understand that meant my mother would rather I be sick than her other beloved offspring.  Many times over the years of my childhood she brought this up – that in essence I couldn’t even be sick RIGHT, which meant NOT SICK ENOUGH.  She hated it that I was not the one to get the worst end of any childhood illness that came through our family.

What was the possible way for me to escape her ambush about this?  There wasn’t any.  I never felt jealous, envious, or angry that her beloved ‘good’ child received her entire approval and resulting loving care.  I had no ability to perceive the world in any other way than the way it was.  Her abuse of be was insidious, had been there since I was born, and was erosive and corrosive of my quality of life and my well-being, and I never even knew it.

++++++++++++++++++

+EXAMPLE OF MY MOTHER’S BORDERLINE ‘GOOD VERSUS BAD THINKING’

++++++++++++++++++++

Although it might not seem to be much of a major ‘thing’, this little excerpt from my mother’s July 7, 1957 letter to father (he’s in Alaska, we’re still in California) paints a very big picture of the contrast in the way my mother felt toward me (nearly 6) and my sister who just turned 4.

This dynamic my mother created with Linda being the BAD child and my sister being the GOOD child existed throughout our childhoods.  There was NOTHING I could do to change how my mother felt about me.  To my mother, I was as innately, inherently and completely a BAD child as my sister was a GOOD one.

My mother wrote:

I was hoping I could tie up our shots here tomorrow but Cindy still can not [sic] have hers.  She’s well (or better) one day and sick the next.

Now she has developed a very bad glandular condition.  On the same order as Linda’s (suppossed [sic] mumps) only much worse!

The big difference is with Cindy.  She never complains and is such a good girl!  Linda would have fussed all over the place.

Today we decided to go out to breakfast for a change and Cindy said she wasn’t hungry.  (She seldom is anymore.)  She looked listless and just not well.  I felt her and she was truly burning up – but it was another ‘scorcher’ of a day!!  But I felt the others and they were not as hot to the touch and I knew Cindy’s heat was not all due to the weather.  She wouldn’t eat so I ordered her some peaches, which she enjoyed.

I felt her glands and her left one under her ear was the size of a small egg!

I brought her right home and took her temperature = 104 [degrees].

This afternoon I brought her to Hankins Medical Group in Azusa.  The doctor gave her a very thorough exam and said it’s a bad cold (or virus) which has settled in her glands.  They gave her a shot and she’s to have two more for the next two days.

Poor darling Cindy!  She never even winces – how I love and adore that child of ours!  She’s such an angel – I die when she’s sick.

I gave her some birthday presents and she was better tonight — .

Oh, Bill the other day All On Her Own she made the sweetest picture, which I’ll send you, of you.  I [sic] when we got married, holding hands.  She did us very well, even – hands, arms feet etc.  The thought was so sweet – she’s our “own love child.”

++++++++++++++++++++

+SILLY EGG IMAGES AND PARENTING – CONTINUED

+++++++++++++++++++

Well, at least I slept last night, though I woke numerous times with odd thoughts in my head!  One of them is related to parenting and eggs.  How?  Think:  Pickled Eggs.

If I picture the early caregiving environment an infant-child is born into as being ‘trauma-toxic’, and then think about pickling eggs, I can better picture how the effects of early trauma changes a little tiny developing body-brain in parallel ways to how soaking an egg in vinegar (with or without spices) will completely change an egg!

Not the same kind of eggs!

When I woke up from whatever odd dream about parents and eggs that I was having last night, I also ‘saw’ one of those nifty hardboiled egg slicers.  If I were to peel a pickled egg and an unpickled egg, and then submit their nice oval shape to the effects of an egg slicer, I would find that what the environment did to the egg completely permeates its constitution.  While the eggs would still equally be eggs, they would be very much changed from one another through and through.

How early maltreatment, trauma, neglect, abuse can stimulate trauma-altered early development is very much like this process.  In cases like my mother’s was, the changes that her body went through in her earliest development (certainly from birth through the age of six) completely changed her through and through.  By the end, nothing was left of her original egg-self.  Influences from her early environment, which also affected the way her genetic code manifested itself, resulted in an entirely different egg-self – through and through.

When I refer to MY mother as ‘My Borderline Mother’ I am referring to this fact.  I had a trauma-changed mother.  If I look at what I know about her very, very closely, I can see the true-egg part of my mother present in her love of the natural world.  That part of who she was born as was not lost.  That part of who she was, I believe, existed so close to the core of who she was that nothing (no one) could change that, in the same way that all the maltreatment my mother did to me never took away from me my love of nature, of plants, of beauty, or of artistic expression through creative use of my hands.

Trauma in infant-childhood CAN and DOES create body-brain changes in development that last a lifetime!

+++++++++++++++++++

+A SILLY IMAGE FOR GOOD VERSUS BAD PARENTING (AND STRESS)?

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

For some reason tonight is not turning out to be a good night for sleeping.  I’m awake and thinking about the pressures that unsafe and insecure attachment conditions create upon a growing infant-child.  When a human being’s earliest development cannot follow the best possible pathway due to early traumas, stress and distress in its relationships with its earliest caregivers, related changes can easily contribute to continued distress for that person for the rest of their lifetime.

So-called mental illness, including Borderline Personality Disorder, and the whole rest of the gamut of brain and nervous system difficulties are being found to often happen because of severe distress and stress during these earliest and most critical ‘windows of development’.  For some reason at this moment this makes me think about early pressure and an egg.

So I looked up the instructions for how to ‘distribute stress just right’ – thinking that this might be an image-experiment that might be like how the stress of life can be handled so much better by a body-brain that was built right from the start in an adequate parenting, safe and secure attachment environment versus how it’s handled by a body-brain that was deprived of these opportunities

++++

I found the following in an article on the wikiHow website:

How to Squeeze an Egg Without Breaking It

originated by:Sondra C, Krystle, Jack Herrick, Ben Rubenstein

SteveSpanglerScience.com – More instructions on this experiment and the source of this article

++++

Here's my pretend newborn baby in its parent's hand - "If you don't do it right - you break it!"

Is it possible to squeeze an egg as hard as you can without breaking it? The answer is – yes! We’ve all learned the hard (and messy) way that eggs can be fragile, but despite their reputation, eggs are amazingly strong. Amaze your friends and yourself by doing this easy experiment.

STEPS WITH ONE HAND:

(1)  Place an egg on your fingers.

(2)  Close your hand so that your fingers are completely wrapped around the egg.

(3)  Squeeze the egg by applying even pressure all around the shell.

(4)  Look at everyone’s amazement (mostly your own) as the egg remains whole and your hand remains dry!

STEPS WITH TWO HANDS:

(1)  Lace your fingers together.

(2)  Place the egg lengthwise between your palms.

(3)  Squeeze your palms together as hard as you can on the points of the egg.

TIPS:

(1)  If you’re a little nervous about the outcome, try sealing the raw egg in a zipper-lock (plastic) bag before putting the squeeze on it, or hold the egg over the sink if you’re in the super brave category. Or go outside and try it.

(2)  Eggs are similar in shape to a 3-dimensional arch, one of the strongest architectural forms. The curved form of the shell distributes pressure evenly all over the shell rather than concentrating it at any one point.

(3)  By completely surrounding the egg with your hand, the pressure you apply by squeezing is distributed evenly all over the egg. However, eggs do not stand up well to uneven forces which is why they crack easily on the side of a bowl.

WARNINGS:

  • Be careful not to wear a ring while squeezing. The uneven pressure of the ring against the shell will result in an amusing display of flying egg yolk.
  • Do not attempt this experiment near carpet, curtains, or any other hard-to-clean item. If this experiment fails, egg yolk will fly in all directions.
  • This only works if you perfectly apply even pressure. Read the discussion page for examples of successful and failed attempts on this trick.
  • One reason why this trick often fails to work, is that even an almost-invisible, hairline crack will cause the egg to break easily, no matter how evenly you apply pressure. The 3D arch structure is indeed very strong, but it only takes one minor flaw to weaken it dramatically. Read up on the Paris Airport Terminal collapse for a larger-scale example of this phenomenon. So inspect the egg very carefully before you try it. If there’s even a hint of a crack, use another egg.
  • Don’t try this in the store before you buy the egg. The storekeeper will not be amused.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

ONLY the affects of infant-child trauma, severe stress and maltreatment during early critical windows of body-brain development are not fun or funny:

Traumatic Childhood Can Reduce Life Expectancy

A difficult childhood reduces life expectancy by up to 20 years according to a study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine. The study found that participants who were exposed to more then five different types of adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) were over 50 percent more likely to die during the 10-year period of the study. On the other hand, people who reported fewer than six ACEs did not have a statistically increased risk of death compared with the control group.

Listen to a podcast Adversce Childhood Experiences and the Risk of Premature Mortality.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

FROM GALLUP:

Introducing the Wellbeing Finder, a revolutionary program for measuring, managing, and improving your wellbeing.

Take the assessment today to see how your Career, Social, Financial, Physical, and Community Wellbeing compare with others.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Introducing the Wellbeing Finder, a revolutionary program for measuring, managing, and improving your wellbeing.

Take the assessment today to see how your Career, Social, Financial, Physical, and Community Wellbeing compare with others.

+MAKING IT CLEAR: MY SYMPATHIES ARE NOT WITH BORDERLINE PARENTS

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

I believe that these blog comments posted in the past few days about Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) (and how I use the term ‘Borderline’ to describe my own mother) are worth a careful, thoughtful read.  If you follow the live links posted below with the comments you can see the original posting the comments were made to and my replies.

Before I launch into my discussion of some of the points of view expressed in these comments, I want to mention some facts as they are appearing in the scientific community about what I call ‘The Borderline Brain’.  Each of these live links below leads to related information in a Google search – and represent the very tip of the proverbial iceberg about how different a Borderline’s brain, nervous system, mind, self, are changed from ‘ordinary’:

(1)  Difficulties in early caregiver infant-child interactions create developmental stress that can lead to a person developing BPD.

(2)  BPD involves a developmentally ‘changed brain’.

(3)  These changes affect all interactions in the brain regarding ‘self reference’

(4)  BPD most often involves an insecure attachment disorder

(5) BPD affects memory

(6)  BPD brain and nervous systems do not process emotion in ordinary ways.  These changes affect someone with a Borderline brain in significant ways that include:

– their brain’s self-referencing resting default mode

– their ability to regulate emotion

–  their ability to experience empathy for others

– their ability to process their life experiences and interactions with others because the development of their Theory of Mind is altered

– their ability to use a human-social skill called ‘mentalizing’ is affected

– all these alterations affect how the Borderline brain-mind operates – and their ‘mind sight’ abilities

(7)  Epigenetic factors that change development are beginning to be recognized in BPD – that affect the way the genetic code manifests (see phenotype and genotype)

(8) All these changes are known to affect a BPD mother’s interactions with her infant and her ability to form safe and secure attachment with her offspring

(9)  The BPD central nervous system is involved, their autonomic nervous system, their vagus nerve system, their stress response, their oxytocin connection system, their immune system, their hormones, and their neurotransmitters – to name just a few of the major influences that Borderline Personality Disorder can create in the body

(10)  BPD can involve delusional disorders and dissociation

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Would you place YOUR well-loved child in the care of someone with life-disorder complications like those described above?  We have to use our common sense – not a BPD strong suit.

When I use the term, ‘my Borderline mother’ I am describing a woman whose physiological existence was probably entirely influenced by the kinds of changes I mention above.  My story is about my life as the abused daughter OF my Borderline mother.

I make no claim to be an expert about BPD.  I am, however, an expert at being the daughter of my Borderline mother.  I had nothing like an ordinary mother.  I had a mother who was a Borderline mother – and a severely disturbed one.

My concern in writing for this blog is ONLY about people who have BPD physiology as it might relate to their ability to safely and securely parent their children.  My concern is WITH THE WELL-BEING OF INFANTS AND CHILDREN.

I do not believe that my mother had any CHOICE about how she behaved toward me and the rest of my family.  The only CHOICE that could have influenced positive change for my mother would have needed to come from the outside and would have needed to be court ordered and professionally enforced.

In essence, I firmly believe that in cases like my mother’s, her children needed to be permanently removed from her care.  Any contact she might have then been able to have with her children would have needed to be strictly (professionally) supervised.

In today’s world of not wanting to be ‘politically incorrect’ we put ourselves at risk for leaving infants and children in dangerously abusive, unsafe and insecurely attached environments with Borderline parents – especially mothers.  There is no comparing – as the commenter below suggests – between an inadequate and/or dangerous BPD parent and a ““lesbian mother” or “over-eater mother”.”  My Borderline mother had no problem with bashing my 4-year-old head in the toilet, for example.

The very last people on this great green and blue earth that we can afford to listen to about the dangers to infants and children of Borderline Personality Disorder parents are PBD parents, themselves – for ALL of the reasons I just pointed out above.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Comment posted by reader to:  MY BORDERLINE MOM

Hi,
It is okay for me if you want to post my comment and also okay if you don’t. Mostly I would like to express my personal feelings about your blog (basically one particular thing).

First, I read your blog on occasion. I am DID [Dissociative Identity Disorder] and can relate to what you write about. I think you do a wonderful work with your blog and it does help others (at least it helps me).

The thing that bothers me is how you slam your “BORDERLINE” mother. I know everything you went thru was terrible (I have my terrible experiences) but as a BPD [Borderline Personality Disorder] mother it really hurts me how you always refer to her as “Borderline Mother” as if all borderline mothers are terrible monsters. I am DID and Borderline and anorexic and . . . . I have 4 outside kids who belong to a 14 yr. old alter who no longer wants them because they are not “babies” any more. I have stepped in and am working really hard to be the best mom I can be. Most of the time my BPD is contained inside (comes with a lot of “inner self-harm” because it does not get released). I do not want that crap released onto these kids.

When other people read your site and are not real familiar with BPD they will assume all BPD moms are out right crazy. Then if they come across my blog and read that I am BPD they will assume I unleash that same crazy stuff onto my kids and I do not. I wish you not refer to your mom as terrible, crazy “Borderline” mom (though I am sure she was). Maybe you could mention she was (is) borderline once or twice and then just refer to her as “crazy, horrible, terrible” instead of slamming the borderline word around when referring to her.

I cringe somewhat when I come to your site, though I like it, because I believe all borderline moms do not behave as such on the outside. I have begged my psychiatrist to remove that label from me but I know I have it. I just hate the way people out there slam it so frequently.

Thanks for listening to me rant! I only wanted to point it out to you. I will still read your site anyway I just do not need to be reminded about how terrible I am.

Thanks

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Next comment posted by this same reader to:  +WORD WARRIOR NEWS: “GO IN PEACE, MY MOTHER.

Hi, I appreciate you listening to my feelings, posting my comments, and leaving it open for others to post also. I am not sure what you are saying in this new post. It seems like you are still saying bad things about borderline mothers, borderlines in general. But I could be totally wrong. When I see borderline and “yanking out the jugular” that does not feel good. Yank YOUR mom’s jugular, not all borderlines behave that way. Why can’t you just say “My Mother” instead of always attaching the BPD with it? You can mention her detailed issues, BPD being one of them, in another place where you explain more about you and your family.

I do not know where I am on the spectrum of borderlines but I can tell you it has to be a conscious effort on my part to think through things before I react. It is a work in progress. I am not the best mom and I lose it at times. I believe any mom can admit that.

One of the beliefs of Dr. Colin Ross (DID expert in Dallas) is that all DID people first split into BPD (that is the FIRST split) then DID comes next. The more I think about it the more I can see this making sense. Some in our system ARE BPD while others are not.

I wonder how others would feel if you were referring to your “lesbian mother” or “over-eater mother”. I do not think it is necessary to continue slamming the BPD label down with the abuses your mother did to you. It is like saying BPD is completely uncontrollable and all of us are crazies who should be in a mental institution.

My mother launched BPD stuff on me all of my life but I would not refer to her as my BPD mom repeatedly. She is my mom and she had a choice not to behave that way but she chose to. I have a choice NOT to behave that way. I am learning a new way.

I understand your anger, your frustration. It just seems you are SO focused on just BPD and not all of the other ways moms abuse their kids. If you abuse kids you abuse them no matter what your diagnosis.

Anyway I am sure my therapist will recommend I stop reading this blog as she does a lot of the blogs I read because it upsets our system. I am thankful to be able to speak up for all of us and express how we feel when we read the BPD references.

Post or not I am okay either way.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Followed in time of posting by this comment by another reader also to:  +WORD WARRIOR NEWS: “GO IN PEACE, MY MOTHER.

Linda, In reading your blog, I would assume that your mother was on the severe end of the borderline spectrum. Borderline personality can manifest itself as extreme anger and violence–it is what it is! The label itself explains much of your mother’s bizarre behavior. I know not all borderline’s are like your mom just like all depressed people don’t stay in bed all day or commit suicide. It’s a matter of degrees but it is what it is!

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Followed by yet another reader to +FOOLED BY AN ABUSIVE BORDERLINE? – MY MOTHER’S EXPERT DISTORTION OF REALITY

Linda,
There would be a quite a lot of people who would call it a bluff. But rest assured, I completely agree with you on this count. Your assessment of BP (borderline personality) is just about perfect. In my case however it is my father and his mother (my grandma) who appear to be the culprits. It appears that BPs are compulsive control-freaks and their entire life revolves around a desperate and somewhat diabolical obsession to take charge of everything and everyone around them. The best option for a non-BP in most situations would be to walk-out on these scheming maniacs without prior warning. As I have observed trying to warn these people of dire consequences if they do not stop their abuse is usually counter-productive. It simply strengthens their resolve to find more innovative ways of abuse. It is only when they [have] no fall-guy left to flog, that they are faced with the terrifying reality of their madness and usually break down irreversibly.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Infants and children born to a Borderline Personality Disorder parent DO NOT HAVE THIS CHOICE:  “The best option for a non-BP in most situations would be to walk-out on these scheming maniacs without prior warning.”

It is up to outside informed and compassionate adults to protect ALL children.  In my opinion, we cannot trust those with Borderline Personality Disorder to parent their infant-child appropriately.  While this fact might not be true in SOME BPD parent cases, my strong suspicion is that as long as we continue to turn away with our blind eyes to the possibilities for severe distortion of reality with a BPD parent’s brain-body-mind that can lead to their offspring’s’ maltreatment, we are risking being contributors to this infant-child maltreatment.

++++

Prevalence:

BPD has a higher incidence of occurrence than schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, and is present in approximately two percent of the general population. BPD has been evidenced in all cultures. It is estimated that between 10 percent of clients in outpatient clinical settings and 15 to 20 percent of those in inpatient psychiatric settings meet the diagnostic criteria for BPD.

Thirty to 60 percent of those presenting with a personality disorder have BPD.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++